President of baseball operations David Stearns has been actively reconstructing the New York Mets’ 2024 lineup, employing relatively low-profile acquisitions and securing just one multi-year contract. This strategic approach raises speculation about the organization’s intentions to pursue prominent players like first baseman Pete Alonso and outfielder Juan Soto in the upcoming free agency period.
According to a report by SNY’s Andy Martino on February 18, there’s a possibility that the Mets are gearing up to make a significant bid for Soto, who is set to begin his tenure with the New York Yankees. While it’s premature to confirm such plans, Martino suggests there’s no apparent barrier preventing the Mets from pursuing Soto.
However, if New York indeed prioritizes Soto and signs him to a contract exceeding $500 million, does this imply that Alonso will be seeking opportunities elsewhere beyond 2025? Not necessarily.
According to insights from a league executive familiar with Mets owner Steve Cohen, there’s speculation that the Mets could pursue both Soto and Alonso simultaneously.
Considering the financial implications, securing both players would involve substantial investments. The Athletic’s Tim Britton estimated Soto’s potential contract at 14 years and $540 million. Meanwhile, Jon Heyman of the New York Post suggested on August 31 that retaining Alonso in Queens could require a commitment of at least $200 million.
Alonso Addressed His Contract Situation at Spring Training
Stearns has been transparent about Alonso’s contract situation, expressing his desire to keep the first baseman with the Mets for the long term. However, he acknowledges that Alonso hitting free agency is the most probable scenario at the moment.
Alonso himself addressed the matter during his first media appearance of the season on February 17.
“My primary goal is to stay healthy throughout the year. I have a deep affection for this team. Becoming a lifelong Met is something I’ve considered,” he stated in Port St. Lucie. “New York holds a special place in my heart and for my family. While I’ve entertained the idea, I can’t foresee the future. Right now, I’m solely focused on this season. My aim is to be the best version of myself, both on and off the field.”
"I definitely have envisioned myself being a lifelong Met, that's something I've definitely thought about. I welcome the idea, but I can't predict the future."
– Pete Alonso pic.twitter.com/VleaKf17s0
— SNY Mets (@SNY_Mets) February 17, 2024
It seems increasingly likely that Alonso will reach free agency. However, if Stearns is genuinely committed to securing Alonso’s long-term presence with the team, initiating discussions would be a proactive step. Alonso revealed that there were no further conversations between his representatives and the Mets this winter beyond the one-year, $20.5 million agreement for the 2024 season.
Adding Soto to the Mets Would Transform the Offense
Though it’s early to speculate, the idea of retaining Alonso and adding Soto to the Mets’ roster is incredibly enticing for fans.
Alonso has already made a mark as one of New York’s top home run hitters, tying Howard Johnson for the fourth-most home runs in Mets history with 192 as he heads into the 2024 season. His three 40-homer seasons stand out, a feat achieved only three times by other Mets hitters before him.
Keeping Alonso as the core of the lineup alongside shortstop Francisco Lindor seems like an obvious choice. Yet, the Mets could benefit from another power hitter to complement Alonso, prompting rumors linking the team to various veteran free agents this offseason.
Bringing in Soto would address that need. At just 25 years old, he consistently threatens to hit 30 homers with impressive stats across his career, including a .284/.410/.519 triple slash over 3,375 plate appearances. Soto boasts accolades like three All-Star appearances, a Home Run Derby victory, a batting title, and four Silver Slugger Awards. Additionally, he played a pivotal role in the Washington Nationals’ 2019 World Series win.
Soto’s addition would undoubtedly elevate the Mets’ lineup, but his appeal extends to virtually every MLB team. The competition for his services will be fierce, and it remains to be seen how serious the Mets are about pursuing both Alonso and Soto in free agency next winter.
